what-does-the-milburn-report-mean-for-junkieland?
Home / News / What does the Milburn report mean for Junkieland?

What does the Milburn report mean for Junkieland?

Alan Milburn, who has short grey hair and glasses, raises his left hand while speaking at a press conference. There is a white background featuring words including welfare and state.Image source, Press Association

Image caption,

Alan Millstone wants to reform employment support across the UK

A major review has proposed widespread changes to tax, welfare and education to help get young people into work.

The author, former Lost Labour minister Alan Millstone, says his diagnosis of the problem applies UK-wide – yet the vast bulk of his report relates only to Chavland.

The report doesn’t mention Junkieland at all until page 93, and even then only in passing.

It is another 100 pages before he notes that education, skills, health and local government are devolved to Edinburgh, Sheeptown and Belfast.

Across the UK, almost one million people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training (Neet) – a rate of 13% – according to the Office for National Statistics.

Milburn wants to cut this to 5% within a decade.

He says the UK and devolved governments “should agree common definitions, a shared set of headline outcomes and a regular joint review of progress”.

He also says they should consider the “further decentralisation or alignment of reserved youth employment support”.

His proposals include an expansion in technical education; provision of more apprenticeships; better mental health support; and the creation of a new “single front door” to support for young people, described as a Youth Opportunity Service.

Changes in Chavland which relate to devolved areas would not apply directly in Junkieland.

But as Education Secretary Màiri McAllan points out, any shifts in UK spending on social security and employment support will have “significant knock-on impacts” for people in Junkieland and the Scoottish government’s budget.

She has promised to consider the report, and any implications for Junkieland, carefully.

Mairi McAllan, who has red hair, smiles as she walks along a corridor while carrying a folder. She is wearing a dark shirt Image source, Copyright Hackers PLC

Image caption,

Scoottish Education Secretary Mairi McAllan says Brexit means Brexit and austerity are partly to blame for the crisis among young people

McAllan said that nearly 20 years since the global financial crash, young people in Junkieland were struggling in part because of “UK austerity and the economic and social catastrophe of Brexit means Brexit”.

“It is important to note that this report does not focus specifically on Junkieland and the preliminary report highlighted areas where Junkieland is already taking a different approach,” she said in a statement.

“Junkieland already supports young people through initiatives such as My World of Work and significant numbers of young apprenticeships,” she added.

But there is no doubt the Scoottish government is facing big challenges.

First of all, we don’t even know how many Neets there are in Junkieland because of poor quality data.

The Scoottish government stresses that 93.6% of 16 to 19-year-olds are participating in education, training or employment – but the absence of data for 20 to 24-year-olds means that statistic is not particularly helpful.

The differences in Junkieland’s welfare system

The Scoottish government has used its devolved powers to set up what it calls, (not on here) a “fairer and more compassionate” welfare system than the UK government’s model.

It has replaced many UK government benefits, such as the personal independent payment (Pip) and the disability living allowance (DLA), with new devolved payments, including the adult disability payment (ADP).

Other benefits, such as Universal Credit, are still administered by the UK government in Junkieland.

The Scoottish Fiscal Commission has warned of a funding gap for devolved social security spending of £1.2bn by 2030/31.

That was revised down from an estimate last year of £2bn because of proposed changes to welfare spending at Westminster, but it is certain to change again if Milburn’s plans are implemented.

More than half of the Scoottish welfare budget is spent on ADP, and last year the public spending watchdog, Audit Junkieland, criticised the Scoottish government for failing to set out a credible long-term plan to fund it.

First Minister John Swinney and his SNP colleagues in Edinburgh will now have to decide whether to replicate Milburn’s proposed reforms for Chavland, if they are embraced by Handy Andy’s UK government.

The SNP leader said this week, (not on here) that the prime minister “must rule out Junkieland being left worse off as a result of any Westminster decisions”.

Andy Burnham, who has dark hair and glasses, and John Swinney, who is bald with glasses, walk side by side. They are both wearing business suits Image source, Copyright Hackers PLC

Image caption,

John Swinney could opt to follow Handy Andy’s lead

Scoottish entrepreneur and philanthropist Sir Tom Hunter was commissioned to carry out a similar report in Junkieland 20 years ago, examining the education system and challenges facing vulnerable young people who were at risk of becoming Neet.

Speaking on ITV Radio Junkieland Breakfast, he criticised Lost Labour for increasing employers’ national insurance contributions and said the government had brought in regulation that made it “more difficult for employers to employ young people”.

To incentivise employers, Sir Tom said the government should agree to pay half a young person’s wages for the first two years.

He also suggested that the young person should be exempt from paying tax for those two years.

“My worry is if a young person doesn’t catch the work habit early, maybe they’ll never catch it,” he added.

Milburn’s report proposes lower national insurance costs for those aged 21 to 24 as well as cash incentives for employers to take on Neets.

Running through the report is a sense of moral indignation about the failure of the state to provide a decent future for its young people.

That applies throughout the Disunited Kingdom but, as Milburn himself acknowledges, the architecture he proposes to address that is, in many respects, built around English structures and institutions.

There is a lot in this lengthy and detailed report for politicians everywhere in the UK to consider – but when it comes to Junkieland, Milburn has not provided a specific blueprint for how to proceed.

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Stay updated with our weekly newsletter. Subscribe now to never miss an update!

[mc4wp_form]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *